On Monday February 8th Ryerson students took to the voting booth to elect their new representatives for the Ryerson Student Union. But what most Ryerson students don’t know is that they may be receiving those nice laminated pieces of campaign material from elected York Federation of Student executives.
Last year the Varsity reported that then president of the YFS, Hamid Osman, and then Vice-President of the YFS, Gilary Massa, both took part in campaigning for the Demand Access slate, who went on to win the elections. This was received with some criticism when it was alleged that Hamid Osman used a fake name when confronted by a member of the opposing slate about his involvement in the Ryerson election. Furthermore, questions of student government sovereignty and interference from foreign student governments were apparent. Hamid Osman is now the Ontario representative for the Canadian Federation of Students. Gilary Massa is now a staff member for the Ryerson Student Union.
This year the story is the same, but this time the players are different. A confidential source informed The York Life that the same events would occur again this year. We were also told that many of the same people from the Demand Access slate are running again in this year’s Ryerson elections under the slate Students United. And some of the people helping campaign for Students United are YFS executives. It was confirmed that Steven Broadley, Zahran Khan and Darshika Selvasivam, three of six YFS executives, were seen handing out Students United campaign material. When they were confronted about their involvement in another student government’s election they said they were “acting as an individual”, were taking “vacation time” from their YFS duties, to “ask” the president of the YFS, “Krisna” Saravanamuttu about their involvement, or “no comment.”
It was also seen that the Executive Director of the YFS, Jeremy Salter, was at Ryerson during the same time near the polling stations. When he was asked for a comment he also said that it would be best to talk to the president. Jeremy Salter is also a former student from Ryerson University.
Naturally, the other slates aren’t too impressed by these foreign campaigners. The LEAD slate candidate for Vice-President of Student Life, Philippe Roy, was asked for his thoughts on this issue of election sovereignty. “When it comes to issues like support for Haiti it’s great that students can come together.” But he also said it’s a bit strange for York student government executives to be campaigning at another universities student election.
So what do York students think about this situation. Iann Mann, a former campaign manager for the York Forward slate during the 2009 elections at York criticized the YFS’s executives behavior. “This is the typical behaviour we’ve seen from Krisna and the former “Students First” slate. Gallivanting around the country, helping out Ryerson friends and the like, when they should be at York, participating in multicultural week, and making York students their number one priority”
This issue of foreign campaigners on vacation was also present at the YFS’s last election. During the voting period Carleton University Students’ Association president, Brittany Smyth, helped hand out campaign material for the Students First Slate. Steven Broadley, Zahran Khan and Darshika Selvasivam are all a part of the Students First slate, which won by a landslide in the election and is now the current YFS administration. The debate grew more complex when it was observed that Smyth wore a sticker saying “I Voted Students First.” She also claimed to be on vacation while handing out campaign material for Students First.
The common theme here seems to be that students help out students from other universities during election time. However, is this help appropriate when it comes from elected officials who do not inform their constituencies that they plan on campaigning at other universities, and does such help make a difference anyways? Furthermore, are their explanations for foreign participation in student elections valid? I guess that’s up for students to decide in this years coming YFS elections.
